Same Nadi and Gunas, Mysticism, reading, forums, Numerology, Sun Signs, Divination

Posts: 5119 · Posted: Tue Apr 07, 2009 4:21 am

Dear Learned Astrologers,

Is marriage compatible if both the boy and girl have same Nadis?

How many Gunas should the couple have to make it a reasonably successful marriage?

I was told that even if the Gunas are less than 18 and planets well placed the marriage can be successful. Is this so?

Awaiting to hear from you all.

Pravin Kumar

Posts: 558 · Posted: Tue Apr 07, 2009 5:46 am

Pravin Kumar wrote:

Dear Learned Astrologers,

Is marriage compatible if both the boy and girl have same Nadis?

How many Gunas should the couple have to make it a reasonably successful marriage?

I was told that even if the Gunas are less than 18 and planets well placed the marriage can be successful. Is this so?

Awaiting to hear from you all.

Pravin Kumar

http://www.astrocamp.com/vedicastrology/2008/09/nadi-dosha-chart-matching.html

total 36 gunas. minimum needed is 18 for average compatibility.
nowadays greedy astrologers give ok to horo compatibility below 18 based on good graha maitri and bhakoota. Marriages may work ( if there necessity to keep marriage) but couple will have to put lot of efforts into marriage ( to survive).

It would not be suffecient to match the gunas but also current planetory positions and Dasa also shud be taken into consideration. there couple of horos matched very well have broken due to bad dasa periods.

also kalatrakaraka Venus to be seen. If venus is cursed then more chance of unhappiness in marriage and broken marriages ( it does not matter if horos match).

Posts: 5119 · Posted: Tue Apr 07, 2009 6:55 am

Dear astro_scholr,

Thanks for your immediately reply. I wish to have your and other learned astrologers views on the following matchmaking horoscope with respect to compatibility:

Boys Date of Birth: 19/2/1982, 10.40 a.m., Bombay. In the first house No.1 Blank, Second House Blank, Third House Rahu, Four House again blank, Fifth house Blank, Sixth House Sat retrograde, Mars, 7th House Jupitor, 8th House Blank, 9th House Ketu, Moon, 10th House Venus and mercury, 11th House Sun and 12th House Blank . Dhanu Raasi as per Moon Sign and Mool Nakshatra in 4th Charan.

In the First House Blank No.12, Second House Blank No.1, Third House Rahu No.2, Fourth House Blank No.3, Fifth House Blank No.4, Sixth House Blank No.5, Seventh House Blank No.6, Eight House Mars and Saturn No.7 (Mars Degree is 28 Degrees, 54' and 35. So it is weak), Ninth House Ketu No.8, 10th House Jupitor No.9, 11th House Venus No.10 and 12th House Moon, Sun and Mercury and No.11.

Kumbh Raasi of Moon Sign and Poorvabhadrapada 1 Pada of the girl. The first detail is of the boy and the second one is of the girl.

Both Nadis are same. According to Gunas Milap it is 14.5.

Both are highly successful in life and career oriented person. What would you suggest about the above Compatibility.

I actually take advise only from 2 famous learned persons on these: One is practising Astrology as a Hobby for past 40 years and has phenomenal success and does not accept any money. The other is also very learned astrologer whom I respect and who does not take any money. One says Nadi Dosh is nullified is the blood group is same as the problem birth of children is there otherwise and it will get considerably delayed. Also Gunas should be above 18. The other says no matter what same Nadi will create problems and if the Gunas are less than 18 and planets are well placed it does not matter.

I would invite your comments on the above. My interest is the boy is known to me.

Pravin Kumar

Posts: 558 · Posted: Tue Apr 07, 2009 9:27 am

girl's DOB,POB,TOB pls .(As need to find compatibility points)

Posts: 5119 · Posted: Tue Apr 07, 2009 10:08 am

Dear A S,

I only know the Date of Birth which is 3/3/1984. As soon as I come to know the other details I shall let you know.

There is another request I have. Another boy was born to a couple I know. I made the horoscope and the birth details are as follows:-

9/3/2009, 1.48 P.M. Bombay.

I made the chart at Indiatimes.com. What I wish to know is: If in the Lagna we have 3 i.e. in the first house and the Lord of 3 i.e. Mercury is in Bhagyasthan as in this case, does the child bring good luck to the parents i.e the astrologers say Mata Pita ka Bhagya Chamak Jata Hai?

Secondly in this case Jupitor is in 8th House. It looks directly at the second house which is Dhansthan. So does the child benefit in life because of this?

Third Sun and Mars are also placed in 9th House as Mercury and Saturn and Moon are placed in 3rd house. Will this create some negative effect? i.e. Moon which is mother and Sun which denotes father both are affected due to Saturn which is Pap Graha.

On the whole general comment on this latter horoscope as to child's financial and education future.

Pravin Kumar