Mangal Dosha, Mysticism, reading, forums, Numerology, Sun Signs, Divination

Posts: 4817 · Posted: Tue Apr 26, 2011 5:47 pm

swetha wrote:

OK.. Correct me if I am wrong...

condition 1 is if suppose mars is in 4th House but present in Cancer ... then does Kuja dosha exist??
RishiRahul= Theoretically it does opt for opt for Kuja dosha cancellalion as per books.
This is actually confusing theoretically. Why?
Mars in cancer with kuja dosha placement or/and Mars in Capricorn with kuja dosha placement, both, opts for cancellation.
Mars in cancer is debilitated and Mars in Capricorn is exalted.
Mars exalted is at the finest of qualities; while Mars debilitated supposed to be the opposite in terms of qualities or least in terms of its (martian) qualities....logically.
How can both these positions refute kuja dosha refute Kuja dosha. Logically only one of these should.
Again Mars in Cancer for Aries lagna would render Arudha Lagna in Cancer, with Mars in Lagna.
This question is for other astrologers.
Can one display examples of Aries lagna with Mars in Cancer and their ages are at least 48 years.
If not... then why do we say Mars in Cancer causes cancellation of kuja dosha? Because of this condition... my program is coming out of checking loop and says no dosha...

But condition 2 if Mars is in 7th house and that is Cancer and lagna or moon is capricorn then --- Kuja dosha does not exist .. this I understand
RishiRahul= Theoretically this should also lead to Kuja dosha.

why am I getting so confused???

Hi Swetha,

Now I am confused. Maybe Govardhantji, or others could help.

RishiRahul

Posts: 2007 · Posted: Sun May 01, 2011 5:44 pm

Swetha

The above link is for your information

The mystic board is a repository of knowledge, many issues like this have already discussed since inception. I am sure some of the late entrants to the board may feel that i am only cutting , copying and pasting . But I am restrained to do so , as the discussion in the past had also taken place

Posts: 1431 · Posted: Sat May 07, 2011 7:17 pm

Hi swetha , Govardhan ji and Rishirahul ji,
It seems to be a nice thread though got bit confusing

I think i will try to help swetha here and not get her more confused.. lollzz

Swetha i think i can understand wats making u get more conufused.. so wud try to help here.

It is rightly said by rishirahul ji that CANCELLATION rules does nt hold ALWAYS since astrology is not purly a science
thats why we need a human to understand the chart completely and softwares cant do that.
Softwares and systems are made to provide DATA and wat we can derive from DATA is called information and
Information can only be DEDUCED by human.

As mentioned by govardhanji giving his own example that he is not separated till not is an INFORMATION not a data..
and who said that mangaliks always end up into SEPARATION thats again a derivation ...Also there can be other good signs in
chart for having ncie marriage not JUST mangalik thing.
Cancellation is part of astrology where
we have to put our own logics and understanding of chart....

Without disrespecting anyone or denying anyones belief..
Wat i wud lik to suggest swetha wud be this.Please concentrate more on data..
Consider mangalik from lagna(1,4,7,8 and 12).
For more data you can also provide the information about the mangliks from moon too (though please do mention specially that this mangalik is from moon).
Also, if you still wnna to add cancellation infrmation then add that in a tooltip expression or a small pop up mentioning about it bcoz adding the cancellation information on ur own wud be like taking decision from the side of native on ur own and providing them with lesser data.

Hope i made sense to you.

Regards,
Raman Deep Singh

Posts: 8526 · Posted: Mon May 09, 2011 5:12 am

thanks for your help. Will work on it