Hello all,

I hope most of the people in this forum have gone through this site at least once and if not kindly go through the site. It has lot of interesting research work done in last 50 years.

http://www.rudolfhsmit.nl/hpage.htm

There was a research carried about by Dean and kelly in UK on timed twins, i.e people born at same place and almost same time published in 2003. Subjects were born on an average of 4.8 min apart and they found absolutely no correlation between the timed twins they took some 110 factors into account and all relations were proved to be less than chance
( The sample pool size was 2101). The subjects were tested at periodic intervals of time in their life at 11, 16, 23

Do any one in this forum know of any research done by vedic astrologers on timed twins and would like to know opinions of others.

Regards,
Gs

Hey Gs ji,
I think u shud go thru PVR Narasimha rao ji's site . You will find a case study something like this only, where 2 twins are researched and explained why they did not have similar life pattern.

That material shud be on our board too but i think it will be easier for you to search it in his site.

Leme try to pull that for you if possible

Regards,
Raman

Hello Raman Ji,

I found PVR ji's post. I am aware of Divisional charts but i have not seen astrologers using beyond navamsa(D-9). They say even though we know our time its only better to look only upto D-9 (and sometimes till D-12).

Generally  in D-9 we get 12-13 minutes window for a lagna and which is considered as acceptable range for birth time.

In PVR ji's example he spoke abt 2 min and that to for twins and in all seriousness two minutes shouldnt be given that much importance and even then only certain house results get effected as we look into D-30, D-60 or higher its not as if entire life of person changes completely with 2 minutes error and there must be at least high correlations. Largely Dasas follow in similar way and certain strong impacts in rasi chart like Debilitated Saturn or placement of rahu in lagna or many other combination's should give effects similarly.

What i am saying is if two timed twins i,e two child's born at same place almost same time for different mothers should in all probability be quite similar in their outlook as they are governed by same planets and lords.

Regards,
Gs

Astrologers mainly follow till D9 because of 2 reasons.        One, being the time frame you mentioned.      Two,  most are not aware of how to see the deeper charts beyond D9.

In twin births I have a data of a native I know personally. Both look very similar and I still get mixed up even when I meet them again.
Their birth times are 2.5 minutes different. Bu considering the dead accuracy of the time which is never the case, I did not get confidence to have a try yet.

The answer is more in the cusps. I mean the star and sub star the house cusp is deposited into.

Both had schooling and similar results in the same years and have similar interests. Met their girlfriends around the same time. But marriage not at the same time. Went to different career streams in the same year... etc. etc.

I propose to correct their charts and do a study sometime, but not getting the time/inclination yet.

RishiRahul

Sometimes with twins one will act as a polarity to the other and they balance each other out. Like I know two twins and one of them has a job an apartment and lives in the system, the other lives out of a back pack practices yoga and is out the the system best he can.