 |
|
Welcome to the MysticBoard.com
You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited
access to view most discussions and access our other features. By
joining our free community you will have access to post topics,
communicate privately with other members (PM), respond to polls, upload
content and access many other special features. Registration is fast,
simple and absolutely free so please, join our community today!
Click
Here to Join MysticBoard.com
If you have any problems with the registration process or your account
login, please
contact us. |
|
sandhu.jp
Age: 45 Zodiac: 
| Joined: 25 Jul 2007 |
| Posts: 617 |
|
Location: (Punjab) India
|
|
 |
Posted: Wed Jun 04, 2008 4:04 am |
|
 |

|
 |
 |
Dear Akshay
Let me source the book of Sh goel, will be back after i iterpret his views in the meanwhile i request the esteemed members to shed some light on the dasha issue.
Regards
J.s.sandhu
Ps- My coming back with a reply may take a few days as , i work in a MNC and it depends on the time i will be able to muster.
| akshaykapoor1973 wrote: |
Sandhuji,
The birth details are as follows:
14 Nov 1973, 5.51 PM, Jallandhar India.
Look forward to your analysis.
Namaskar |
|
|
|
 | Re: Shadashottari Dasha Conundrum- Antardasha's Opposite??? |  |
|
RishiRahul
Astrology Reader
Age: 53 Zodiac: 
| Joined: 24 Feb 2007 |
| Posts: 4815 |
|
Location: Calcutta, New York, Toronto
|
|
 |
Posted: Thu Jun 05, 2008 3:54 pm |
|
 |

|
 |
 |
| sandhu.jp wrote: |
Dear Rishi ji, Akshay ji,
Sh KN rao thinks very highly about the Author Sh Goel , who is a faculty member at his school of astrology. I was going through an interview of Sh rao on a site , where'in' he held the book of sh goel in very high esteem. He said he prefered the use of chara dasha . Unfortunately i lost the link due to a power failure, i will post the same once i find the link & if moderators' allow the same. I personaly feel that one should use a tool only when one is adept at its use, the hit and trial method has margin of errors, anyway Akshay ji , use the shadashottari dasha on known and familiar cases of your data and share the results with us all if any semblence of difference is there, The inputs by Vivek ji are just the right rescource that you will need . This question posted by you on another forum , has elicted the same response that you should try to find the answers by Trying the strengths of assertions of SH goel. In fact the answer is that you should go by Sh goels opinion. Anxiously waiting to hear from you.
Regards
J.s.sandhu
| akshaykapoor1973 wrote: |
Namaskar,
Ive come across a very interesting conundrum. The maha dasha's in shodashottari follow the sequence ..Sun, Mars, Jupiter, Saturn, Ketu, Moon, Mercury, Venus. However what sequence do the antardashas follow.
In BPHS as translated by GC Sharma and in a book on Shadashottari dasha by VP Goel under KN Rao's guidance, it is written that the 1st antardasha is of the Mahadasha lord and then the same sequence as the Mahadasha follows...so in Ketu Mahadasha antardashas would be Ketu , Moon, Mercury.....just like in the Vimshottari Dasha system.
Would you agree? A very well regarded astrologer of the Pt Rath school says its exactly the opposite. ie in Ketu Mahadasha, antardashas would be Sat, Jup, Mars, Sun.....
Any views? |
|
Hello Sandhuji,
Rightly said, the chara dasas should be wisely used for finer tunings. It being a part of Vedic Astrology has much wisdom. But Vimshattari dasa, I feel . should be the main. t is like plasticine and most marriagable, like vodka and Gin amongts alcohols. It talks of all angles.
In radios and other musical gadgets, the sound would never be complete without fine tuning.
The result of Shodashottari dasa, I am aware of, but would not try to create bias, but would leave it to experiment; and will post details hen I am reasonably free to concentrate.
Rishiahul
|
|
|
 |
 | Re: Shadashottari Dasha Conundrum- Antardasha's Opposite??? |  |
|
sandhu.jp
Age: 45 Zodiac: 
| Joined: 25 Jul 2007 |
| Posts: 617 |
|
Location: (Punjab) India
|
|
 |
Posted: Thu Jun 05, 2008 4:10 pm |
|
 |

|
 |
 |
Dear Rishi ji
I agree with you , In fact i am not dextrous enough to deal with Shodashottari dasa and there are not very many people who can use the
dasha accurately, for experimentation and learning the finer nuances its ok. Even RR in his book crystal jyotish agrees to the effectiveness of vimoshottari dasha system.
Regards
J.s.sandhu
Hello Sandhuji,
Rightly said, the chara dasas should be wisely used for finer tunings. It being a part of Vedic Astrology has much wisdom. But Vimshattari dasa, I feel . should be the main. t is like plasticine and most marriagable, like vodka and Gin amongts alcohols. It talks of all angles.
In radios and other musical gadgets, the sound would never be complete without fine tuning.
The result of Shodashottari dasa, I am aware of, but would not try to create bias, but would leave it to experiment; and will post details hen I am reasonably free to concentrate.
Rishiahul[/quote]
|
|
|
 |
 | Re: Shadashottari Dasha Conundrum- Antardasha's Opposite??? |  |
|
sandhu.jp
Age: 45 Zodiac: 
| Joined: 25 Jul 2007 |
| Posts: 617 |
|
Location: (Punjab) India
|
|
 |
Posted: Mon Jun 09, 2008 2:58 pm |
|
 |

|
 |
 |
Dear All here is what Rohini ranjan says About Dasha Usage, In his book Crystal pages Jyotish.
CHAPTER V: TIMING, THE VIMSHOTTARI DASHA PROGRESSION
The vimshottari dasha system for timing of events is an important technique in vedic astrology.
Ancient masters had described numerous systems of dashas (planetary periods) in their works. Whether all
of those were fully-tested techniques is very hard to decipher. Most vedic texts are collections of Sanskrit
verses in which the old masters had inscribed in an ornate, yet poignant manner the various planetary effects,
but only rarely did they provide accompanying illustrative examples. Over the years, later astrologers have
attempted to test the validity of many of these dashas using approaches that have varied tremendously in
their degree of acuity, rigor and objectivity. Most contemporary experts in vedic astrology agree that, if the
proof of the pudding is in the eating, vimshottari dasha (based on lunar progression) is probably one of the
most valid and accurate systems for timing of events not only in natal charts but also in annual, national
(mundane) and horary horoscopes. This is not to imply that the Kalachakra, Yogini and Jaimini dashas that
have found a new lease in life, recently, are not to be taken seriously. In fact, utilizing more than one dasha
almost invariably leads to better insights into timing of a specific event because of the enhanced opportunity
for (weight of evidence) confirmation that is available when several methods for tracking of the astrological
signatures underlying expected events are used. However, the beginner should first learn vimshottari and this
is what we will focus on, primarily in this course and when we refer to dasha, it must be taken to mean
vimshottari dasha.
Regards
J.s.sandhu
| sandhu.jp wrote: |
Dear Rishi ji
I agree with you , In fact i am not dextrous enough to deal with Shodashottari dasa and there are not very many people who can use the
dasha accurately, for experimentation and learning the finer nuances its ok. Even RR in his book crystal jyotish agrees to the effectiveness of vimoshottari dasha system.
Regards
J.s.sandhu
Hello Sandhuji,
Rightly said, the chara dasas should be wisely used for finer tunings. It being a part of Vedic Astrology has much wisdom. But Vimshattari dasa, I feel . should be the main. t is like plasticine and most marriagable, like vodka and Gin amongts alcohols. It talks of all angles.
In radios and other musical gadgets, the sound would never be complete without fine tuning.
The result of Shodashottari dasa, I am aware of, but would not try to create bias, but would leave it to experiment; and will post details hen I am reasonably free to concentrate.
Rishiahul |
[/quote]
|
|
|
|
|
 |
 |
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum You cannot attach files in this forum You can download files in this forum
|
All times are GMT
Page 3 of 3
|
|
|
|
Why Join mysticboard.com |
| Free registration. Friendly, fun, & open environment. Share, learn, & make friends all at the same time. Daily Horoscope. Your very own Personal Astrology blog. |
| For Experts / Professionals: |
|
Professional exchange of ideas. Common ground to meet like minded experts. Bring about awareness & dispel myths. Share & Gain from experiences. Interact with amateurs & encourage them. |
| For General Members: |
| An opportunity to meet
& talk to people from all walks of life. Make new friends.
Exchange ideas, share your thoughts & debate over
interesting issues. Have thought provoking Discussions with
Experts & Amateurs. Create your own Personal Astrology Blog
and share it with friends. |
| For Amateurs: |
| Be
informed with the latest updates. Free exchange of ideas and information. Sharpen your skills by practice & expert guidance. Gain from expert advice. Interact with the Experts / Professionals. |
| For Skeptics: |
| Participate in a healthy debate; An open unbiased forum to voice your beliefs. |
|
**
REGISTER NOW ** |
|
RSS RSS 2.0 XML
Powered by phpBB | phpBB Style created by phpBBStyles
|  |