Please no puranas... just some one let me know which one is proven by masters... no long essays please...

One coulg go thru a previous mysticboard discussion  on this topic:



My views are pasted below (mentioned in the above viewtopic.

Posted: Fri Mar 16, 2007 6:34 pm


I am quite new to the forum, and totally unaware ofthe ayanamsa bit until Swethaji apprised me about it.
Out of the so many ayanamsas available in our planet Earth, in my experience 4 seems very authentic with Vimshottari and Yogini dasas. 3 of them are Indian made ayanamsas  namely 1)B.V. Ramans 2) K.P.3)N.C.Lahiri. The 4th one is by a Western. It is Fagan ayanamsa.

Considering that the K.P. system of seeing with the help of star and sublord needs proper degrees and minutes for correct predictions,( also the nos 1 - 249 horary method) I have seen that the N.C. and K.P. ayanamsa works best with it.
Someone could research between the 2 ayanamsas while usingthe K.P.horary(1 - 249 method). They work very well with yogini dasa too. Please note that the difference between them is ony 7 minutes, which is negligible when compared to the other above mntiones ayanamsas.

The ayanamsha of B.V.Raman is not incorrect too, but in fact quite accurate, but the method of giving readings with it needs a slight adaptation. To the best I can explain,by writing in this esteemed forum, is that the natural qualities/ karak qualities of the planets reflect better using this dasa. Sharp changes in mentality of the native is seen when he experiences dasa/antardasa changes while using B.V. Raman ayanamsa.
One more thing: Say if Saturn Mahadasa starts in June 2007 for a native as per N.C./KP ayanamsa, then Saturn dasa will arrive as per B.V. ayanamsa ( 9 months/13 months/24 months) before June 2007( depending on the starting dasa and antardasa. Suppose as per B.V. ayanamsa Saturn dasa started in Sept 2006:= The Saturns slowing down effect was cast invisibly from that period, like a shadow in the natives life from then. From june 2007 saturns dasa will start taking the functional qualities of Saturn.
A life progession will be noted when we follow antardasas while using Fagan ayanamsa and can judje the where and how the dasa will land us.

This is what I am able to share with you in writing. The rest has to be explained properly with actual charts. Some times what we try to explain in writing is not fully understood by the readers as we have different skils in communicating abilities.

Till I hear from you all.
RishiRahul

While using N.C./K.P. we, naturally use the natural and functional qualities of planets as mentioned in hindu astrology.


Questions/clarifications are welcome.

RishiRahul

Thank you for your immediate reply Rahul.

According to KN Rao NC Lahri is the preferred one. He also says it should be slightly changed, do you know the change?

Regards

Rajesh

[quote="Rajesh Kakkanatt"]Please no puranas... just some one let me know which one is proven by masters... no long essays please...[/quote]

MASTERS, and by that I presume you meant classical masters like Parashara, Vedavyaasa, Satyacharyaa, Varahamihira (& Kalidasa, Dhundiraja, Mukunda Vallabha etc etc) DID NOT recommend any ayanamsha or even mentioned, let alone proved any ayanamsha actually! WHY? You will have to find them to get the answer!

modern masters have given different values, each vouched in blood by them and their disciples. You pick the drummer that you have chosen to march too! Most of these 'followers' may not have actually tested their teacher's ayanamsha in a scientific or even documented way and are experiencing Bhakti Yoga, candidly speaking!!

How is that for a short but honest essay?

RR

Thank you Rohinirajan for your kind reply. But I have a doubt, why then if Classic masters did not mention regarding Ayanmsa, its so important to us and why all calculations depend upon it?

Best Regards

Rajesh Kakkanatt