What is the effect if a Mangalik boy marries a Non Mangalik girl with 22 Gunas matching in the Horoscope.

Difficult to answer because its not just mangalik or non mangalik which is important, but mangalik dosh is there or not, and if it is there, whethere dosh Bhang is also there in the kundli or not?, all these issues are important...In general I would say that Mangalik guys are hard working, honest, if other bad combinations are not there, brave, although hot tempered, with risk taking attitudes.

Hemal

Thanks Hemal,
How do you decide about the presence of Dosh or Dosh Bhang in a Mangalik person..

[quote="drsrtiwari"]Thanks Hemal,
How do you decide about the presence of Dosh or Dosh Bhang in a Mangalik person..[/quote]

Dear *Readers*,

Very interesting topic, if you don't mind me butting in, into this public conversation!

Few preliminaries to be addressed first, in my meagre experience and light brushes with the profound ocean of astrology and so on ...

Is Mangal Dosha indeed a well-defined, sure to strike natural disaster?

Once that "gutthi"/KNOT is solved or resolved, then we can begin to take the next steps.

For the time being, I park the mangal-dosh issue on this thread as a scare crow!

This is not a definitive statement or final nail on the coffin of mangal dosha, mind you, because IT IS REAL, but it is not LITERAL or UNIVERSAL!

Threads like these have been formed again and again on this topic and on many other BOOGIE men that classics have proposed or more truthfully that have been overamplified by contemporary *experts* and other misinterpretations, here there and everywhere ...

As before, I am challenging your emotions -- to look at this matter rationally!

Let us receive, honestly, one example with full birthdata etc of mangal dosha that created havoc for a couple and let us look at that chart slowly and one at a time to see if there were ALTERNATIVE EXPLANATIONS!

This is the approach that led me to the awareness that combustion as considered by traditional jyotish is not to be accepted lock stock and barrel and CAIZIMI is not to be glossed over just because it did not get observed/recorded/documented in the so called vedic texts that we cling to!

RR

Dear RR,
Thanks for your participation in this topic. Your approach is most rationale and scientific. Unless we dissect out the prevalent but indigestible beliefs, till we can bring out the co relationship between various factors, we cannot claim to say anything authorotatively. So coming along with you in this matter, I shall wait to listen more from you.