I can vouch for Virgos being a pretty good match for Scorpio. My soon to be ex is a Virgo and it was really good for more than half of our 6 years together. Problem is we let our shadow selves come out instead of working on ourselves we ended up in a power play, manipulation, greed and posessiveness. Although we are ending as friends because of our daughter he didn't work on himself spirtually and neither did I to grow and walk a path together, instead we grew apart and destroyed what could have been a wonderful long lasting relationship. He decided to move on with a Cancer woman that he fell in love with while we are together. I don't see them lassting and I predict he will be back to me but not before he has learned cosmic lessons and I learn mine.

I'm a Scorpio but I found myself always attracted to Leo's and Aries'. Virgos were the ones I felt LEAST compatible with. They were often ones that annoyed me to the extreme! Often, but, not always. ;)

Hey there fellow Scorpio friends!   I was married to a pisces for almost 17 years. Incidentially, he is engaged now to another Scorpio so obviously he has a certain affinity to us! I am dating and will marry the love of my life, a wonderful Capricorn! He is the yin to my Yang and I've never been happier. Before him, I dated another Scorpio which was an extremely intense experience and one that I needed after my divorce but not one I would have been happy with throughout the rest of my life. This issue of who we are most compatible with is leaving out one component...the sign we are most compatible with depends on where we are in life, what we need to fulfill in our lives at that moment, what we need to learn or experience. I needed the pisces during that time of my life and subsequently, perhaps he needed me to prepare him for his new Scorpio in his life now. I certainly feel I am a better woman and wife because I remember my experiences with him, making mistakes, refining my sting, which prepared me for my Capricorn love now. Think back over past relationships and how grateful you can be for those experiences, even if they didn't work out...they simply were what you needed at that time in order to prepare you for a better, happier life (if we will but learn from those experiences).

What do you all think? Do you agree that compatibility depends a lot on where we are in our lives at that particular time? ~ jules