Mystic Board - Free Astrology, Tarot to Psychic  Discussion BoardWelcome to Mystic Board - Free Astrology, Tarot to Psychic Discussion Board. New visitors: Register Now its FAST!      Members, please Sign-In.
Log In  
 
Presenting to you the World's Largest Mystic Scripts Library
Click Here To Visit Mystic Scripts Online Library

Welcome to the MysticBoard.com

You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, communicate privately with other members (PM), respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join our community today!
Click Here to Join MysticBoard.com

If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please
contact us.




Reply to topic
vivekvshetty


Age: 45
Zodiac:
Gemini



Joined: 15 Jan 2007
Posts: 961
Location: India
Reply with quote
Namaskaar All,
We are very happy that at least two learners have tried to attempt this question.
Learners can see two different approaches in the reading even within the parameters defined. This is true of every chart and every Jyotish will approach the same chart differently.

we offer our comments on the answers. remember we are only commenting on the points raised by the learners and have not given our own take on the chart. We want it be a learning experience only.
let us see Swapnil ji's approach first.

Quote:
1. the seventh bhaava
Budha is in 7th which is MKS for him in rashi also not in frendly rashi but vargottam.
What does maranakaaraka do to this chart? what does enemy sign do? what does vargottam do? Budha is the lord of the 6th and the 9th also.how will this effect?

2. the Seventh lord

7th lord soma is aslo in its MKS in rashi but interestingly vargottam

What does 7th lord in the 8th hint at? what does Maranakaaraka do? what does vargottama do?
3. the Kaaraka
Shukra karaka for marriage is in own sign also placed good but with malefics
How do the malefic/s effect Shukra what is the impact? why ignore 7th from Shukra?
DK budha is in MKS again also to apply karako naso bhava
Budha as the Daarakaaraka in the 7th can be termed as Kaarako bhaava Naasha, what is it that is getting naasha? how is it placed from the AK? Is not the maranakaaraka of DK a factor to be taken into account?

4. the upapada
UL in 9th and itslord budha again
What happens when Ul is in the 9th Bhaava? how is it placed from the AL? does the UL and AL enjoy good dynamics?
What is the result of UL and A7 placed together? Also see the second from UL to see the longevity of the Marriage.

5. the Daarapada
Its in 9th also again lorded by budha A7 is in trikona to AL may be having good complany of opp sex

6. the navaamsha.
I dont know much about navamsa but i know that 7th in D9 is important for marriage here 7th have yuti of rahu and shukra there may be some type of cheating to native from partner
7th lord is in 8th from it with navamsa lagna lord in 2nd
What result will the underlined statement of yours give?

seventh bhaava in D-9 is after marriage, seventh lord in D-9 is during marriage. Seventh lord is with Chandra and Mangal, what does it show about the type of marriage? Also dont miss out the eighth as it will impact the marriage.

7. the Panchaanga factor.
Here thithi lord (jala) is shukra and varesh (agni) is guru so may be problem also shukra guru in 2/12 position in rashi
Why take the vaara lord into account? Shukra as the Tithi lord is placed in the 5th itself and so the basic complaint of the spouse will be of the native being more self centered and also the worship factor. if this is a marriage with a partner from another religion then it will have great impact.
Conclusion

May be concerned native has bad marriage or more than one
If we take only the factors you have taken into account, then we doubt we can reach such a sure conclusion. You may be right but the approach has to be more thorough. Remember the great responsibility of counselling the person coming for advice from you.


CRS ji.
Quote:
1. the seventh bhaava

Is afflicted by presence of 6th lord . Me being in enemy's house and in the nakshtra of functional malefic Ju, and the fact that it is the DK, may lead to multiplicity of relations and trouble with relations. Cause of trouble may be the maternal uncle or due to/in the process of/lack of learning. 7th bhava dn Me are also Rasi Drishti of Ve,Ra,Ma from 5th.

2. the Seventh lord

Is afflicted by being in 8th. Also weak in paksha bala. But placed in friend's house. I consider it weak to defend what it owns specially since 8th lord Su is in 6th. It is almost like 6th and 8th lords are conspiring against 7th and 7th lord!

3. the Kaaraka

Ve the karaka is also the yogakaraka, placed in swakshetra, but afflicted by conjunction with Ma and Ra and also 3rd aspect of Sa. Overall appears to be weak.
This is a very serious affliction. More than two Malefics afflicting a Graha or/and  bhaava should make the jyotish give particular attention to the Kaarakatva, lordship and the Bhaava. Graha Dristhi is very important for this. Here we see that the Kaarakatwa is spoiled and the area of life ruled by the Kaarakatva will surely be affected.
4. the upapada

UL being the 9th and UL lord being in 7th and lagnesh Sa being in 7th from UL probably assures marriage.

5. the Daarapada

Same as UL

6. the navaamsha.

Me in lagna with full digbala and vargottama assures marriage despite conjunct Ke and Ra's aspect.
Presence of Ra dn Ve in 7th is not good for trouble free relations and specially marriage.

7. the Panchaanga factor.

Vaaresh Ju is ill placed in 6th in enemy's house. Health problems can be forseen specially since Ju is also a functional benefic.
When trying to decipher the marital aspect of the native it is the Tithi lord which is given importance and not the vaaresh.

Overll 7th house appears to be the primary action bhava for the native. Marriage may have taken place in Mo-Me-Me period.

Why not Mo-SA?
Over all we are very satisfied with both the replies and both have added more than we have learnt in the course. this shows that they are both doing self study also.

RishiRahul and vivek.
gaonkarswapnil


Age: 28
Zodiac:
Capricorn



Joined: 12 Feb 2008
Posts: 372
Location: mumbai
Reply with quote
Dear Vivek ji

Here are answers to few questions as per my understanding till now

Marnakaraka is the place where planet is not in happy state just as you explained about the mangal been bhramachari will not be happy in 7th as it is so called house of pleasures so if he is placed there he will better to die than to stay here

I 1st looked bhava then planet in it then the lord of it then karaka

In this case it was 7th the planet in it was not happy it self so he wont do work of that particular house up on that he is in enemy sign next the 7th lord was in 8th also its MKS nither he comes to rescue i read that 7th in 8th shows some kind of debts from marriage now the karaka here too heemed between malefics so if we look rashi 7th is not good but the intresting part is the budha is vargottam as per my understanding it gives fame related to that graha may be the native is a good learner also vargottam quality gives blessings from god or luck factor as it is linked to navamsa

About the karko naso bhava i read in some article i dont exactly remember but i think it was pandit jis article mentioning about this that chara karaka should be looked in for this stance (correct me if i am wrong) where he mentioned about shukra in 7th is not good but if up on that shukra happned to be DK then it is more bad

I dont know much about UL in 9th but i think it would bring luck to native as 9th is house of luck as you said UL shows body of spouse so i mentioned about the spouse looks from that particular rashi characteristic since UL is placed in trine to AL they sure enjoy good dynamics

UL and A7 placed together shows long time friendship turning in to marriage now 2nd from UL is lorded by shukra which is heemed between malefics so there may be fights or divorce

7th lord is in 8th from it with navamsa lagna lord in 2nd ?

About the above question i meant is in navamsa 7th lord shani is in 2nd and navamsa lagnesh is also in 2nd which says more than one marriage

seventh bhaava in D-9 is after marriage, seventh lord in D-9 is during marriage. Seventh lord is with Chandra and Mangal, what does it show about the type of marriage? Also dont miss out the eighth as it will impact the marriage

Please explain this in detail as i dont know much about this

Vaara lord was mistake from my side thiti lord should be taken in account as it shows complains spouse will have w r t native

Pardon me for my mistakes as you know i am just a learner

Regards

Swapnil
mysbcrs


Age: 51
Zodiac:
Pisces



Joined: 15 Apr 2009
Posts: 217

Reply with quote
Dhanyavaad Vivekji,

Here are my answers (attempted) to your questions:

3. Effect of afflicted karaka

Affliction from Ma may indicate problems due to landed property which may manifest by way of harsh speech.
Affliction by Ra may indicate problems due to money matters and greed. Combo with Ma may indicate disputes to debts.

Consequently all relationships mayl have these undercurrents.

7. Thithi lord Ve in own house is good. Relatinships initiated on thithis owned by Ve get protected to some extent.


Quote:
Why not Mo-SA?


I felt Sa is a weaker signifactor of marriage due to the following:

1. It is not connected to 7th in natala, only to 7th from UL
2. In its own nakshtra without any benefic connection
3. Placed in 8th from 7th lord Mo
4. Placed in 8th house of natal in D-9

On the other hand Me looks stronger due to:

1. Being DK, 9th and UL lord
2. Is in Ju nakshatra and is dispositor of Ju who owns 12th house of bed comforts also aspecting it.

CRS
vivekvshetty


Age: 45
Zodiac:
Gemini



Joined: 15 Jan 2007
Posts: 961
Location: India
Reply with quote
Namaskaar CRS ji,
Great attempt. Allow us to comment on some of your observations.

mysbcrs wrote:
Dhanyavaad Vivekji,

Here are my answers (attempted) to your questions:

3. Effect of afflicted karaka

Affliction from Ma may indicate problems due to landed property which may manifest by way of harsh speech.
Affliction by Ra may indicate problems due to money matters and greed. Combo with Ma may indicate disputes to debts.

Consequently all relationships mayl have these undercurrents.
Yes! the kaaraka is the most important factor while judging any Bhaava. Affliction to it will color the whole matter it signifies.
All the affliction happening in the Al will also affect his image and dent it severely.

7. Thithi lord Ve in own house is good. Relatinships initiated on thithis owned by Ve get protected to some extent.
Why will relationships started on Shukra's tithi get protected? this is something new for us. Where did you learn this?


Quote:
Why not Mo-SA?


I felt Sa is a weaker signifactor of marriage due to the following:

1. It is not connected to 7th in natala, only to 7th from UL
2. In its own nakshtra without any benefic connection
3. Placed in 8th from 7th lord Mo
4. Placed in 8th house of natal in D-9

On the other hand Me looks stronger due to:

1. Being DK, 9th and UL lord
2. Is in Ju nakshatra and is dispositor of Ju who owns 12th house of bed comforts also aspecting it.
Good point.

CRS


RishiRahul and vivek.
vivekvshetty


Age: 45
Zodiac:
Gemini



Joined: 15 Jan 2007
Posts: 961
Location: India
Reply with quote
Namaskaar Swapnil ji,
Our questions was as to the first Sentence. We qoute it here.
"Budha is in 7th which is MKS for him in rashi also not in frendly rashi but vargottam."

We want a reading and not the technical points. To a person coming to you for a reading this line will not mean anything.  This is a common problem with every learner and she/he has to get out of this. knowing a principle is good but applying it to read charts is something different. We have pointed this out not to discourage but to see and face this before it becomes a problem.
gaonkarswapnil wrote:
Dear Vivek ji

Here are answers to few questions as per my understanding till now

Marnakaraka is the place where planet is not in happy state just as you explained about the mangal been bhramachari will not be happy in 7th as it is so called house of pleasures so if he is placed there he will better to die than to stay here

I 1st looked bhava then planet in it then the lord of it then karaka

In this case it was 7th the planet in it was not happy it self so he wont do work of that particular house up on that he is in enemy sign next the 7th lord was in 8th also its MKS nither he comes to rescue i read that 7th in 8th shows some kind of debts from marriage now the karaka here too heemed between malefics so if we look rashi 7th is not good but the intresting part is the budha is vargottam as per my understanding it gives fame related to that graha may be the native is a good learner also vargottam quality gives blessings from god or luck factor as it is linked to navamsa

About the karko naso bhava i read in some article i dont exactly remember but i think it was pandit jis article mentioning about this that chara karaka should be looked in for this stance (correct me if i am wrong) where he mentioned about shukra in 7th is not good but if up on that shukra happned to be DK then it is more bad

I dont know much about UL in 9th but i think it would bring luck to native as 9th is house of luck as you said UL shows body of spouse so i mentioned about the spouse looks from that particular rashi characteristic since UL is placed in trine to AL they sure enjoy good dynamics

UL and A7 placed together shows long time friendship turning in to marriage now 2nd from UL is lorded by shukra which is heemed between malefics so there may be fights or divorce

7th lord is in 8th from it with navamsa lagna lord in 2nd ?

About the above question i meant is in navamsa 7th lord shani is in 2nd and navamsa lagnesh is also in 2nd which says more than one marriage

seventh bhaava in D-9 is after marriage, seventh lord in D-9 is during marriage. Seventh lord is with Chandra and Mangal, what does it show about the type of marriage? Also dont miss out the eighth as it will impact the marriage

Please explain this in detail as i dont know much about this

Vaara lord was mistake from my side thiti lord should be taken in account as it shows complains spouse will have w r t native

Pardon me for my mistakes as you know i am just a learner

Regards

Swapnil

RishiRahul and vivek.
Lesson 18. Let us start applying the knowledge gained.
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum
You cannot attach files in this forum
You cannot download files in this forum
All times are GMT  
Page 2 of 13  


 
 Reply to topic  

Why Join mysticboard.com

Free registration. Friendly, fun, & open environment. Share, learn, & make friends all at the same time. Daily Horoscope. Your very own Personal Astrology blog.
For Experts / Professionals:
Professional exchange of ideas. Common ground to meet like minded experts. Bring about awareness & dispel myths. Share & Gain from experiences. Interact with amateurs & encourage them.
For General Members:
An opportunity to meet & talk to people from all walks of life. Make new friends. Exchange ideas, share your thoughts & debate over interesting issues. Have thought provoking Discussions with Experts & Amateurs. Create your own Personal Astrology Blog and share it with friends.
For Amateurs:
Be informed with the latest updates. Free exchange of ideas and information. Sharpen your skills by practice & expert guidance. Gain from expert advice. Interact with the Experts / Professionals.
For Skeptics:
Participate in a healthy debate; An open unbiased forum to voice your beliefs.

** REGISTER NOW **







RSS RSS 2.0 XML