Lesson 10- Benefics and Malefics (Functional and Natural), Mysticism, reading, forums, Numerology, Sun Signs, Divination

Posts: 961 · Posted: Fri Jun 12, 2009 3:50 pm

Namaskaar CRS ji,
We think it is because a Yoga kaaraka's (a functional benefic) placement in the bad Bhaavas is bad.
Shani is the natural kaaraka for these Bhaavas and its placement in one of them gives the Vipareeta result.
The Bad is reversed to good.
RishiRahul and vivek.

Posts: 217 · Posted: Sat Jun 13, 2009 7:02 am

Dhanyavaad Vivekji,

Quote:

We think it is because a Yoga kaaraka's (a functional benefic) placement in the bad Bhaavas is bad.
Shani is the natural kaaraka for these Bhaavas and its placement in one of them gives the Vipareeta result.
The Bad is reversed to good.

Does this mean that for a Kumbha,Mithuna or Kanya lagna placement of shani in 6/8/12 is very auspicious? In these cases Shani owns a trine and placement in 6/8/12 meets the "dusthana lord in dusthana" criteria apart from "karaka in the house of karakatwa destroying malefic significance" criteria.

CRS

Posts: 961 · Posted: Sat Jun 13, 2009 3:21 pm

Namaskaar CRS ji,
Tell us what you think.
RishiRahul and vivek.

Posts: 217 · Posted: Sat Jun 13, 2009 5:36 pm

Namaskaar Vivekji,

Since I have no exposure to practical analysis of charts, I will have to answer this based on whatever I have read (which is not much) and whatever I have understood (which is of-course even lesser

). Hope you will correct me.

I feel placement of Shani in dusthana in general can also lead to some good results (containment of bad effects), though the evil effects are not fully nullfied.

As for kaaraka destroying the significance of house if placed there, I keep reading affirmations and exceptions. I again get a mixed feel (not all effects are destroyed...).

As for comparison between placement of Shani in 6/8/12 in Vrishabh/Tula as against Kumbh/Mithuna/Kanya, I feel it should prove more auspicious for the latter since in the former case, as a single handed yogakaaraka it gets locked up in dusthana and in addition does not own any dusthana.

CRS

Posts: 961 · Posted: Thu Jun 18, 2009 4:27 pm

Namaskaar CRS ji,
You seem to have missed the word 'Vipareeta" in our reply.
RishiRahul and vivek.

mysbcrs wrote:

Namaskaar Vivekji,

Since I have no exposure to practical analysis of charts, I will have to answer this based on whatever I have read (which is not much) and whatever I have understood (which is of-course even lesser

). Hope you will correct me.

I feel placement of Shani in dusthana in general can also lead to some good results (containment of bad effects), though the evil effects are not fully nullfied.

As for kaaraka destroying the significance of house if placed there, I keep reading affirmations and exceptions. I again get a mixed feel (not all effects are destroyed...).

As for comparison between placement of Shani in 6/8/12 in Vrishabh/Tula as against Kumbh/Mithuna/Kanya, I feel it should prove more auspicious for the latter since in the former case, as a single handed yogakaaraka it gets locked up in dusthana and in addition does not own any dusthana.

CRS