Hi Jedi, while I can't tell you why you're having such a hard time, I can see where there will be opportunity a bit later on.
In this horoscope, you're the Moon who is in detriment in the Seventh house. This seems to sum you up quite nicely as someone who is upset and confused about love matters.

The Moon does hold some dignity in Capricorn at night, so I feel this shows that you at least have your faculties about you enough to try to move on in a healthy way, which is good.

While this doesn't really hold any new information in and of itself, it does validate me in thinking that this is the appropriate chart for your situation.

The Moon has recently passed a Square to Venus who I'm thinking would indicate your last girlfriend. How long ago did the break up occur? I feel it could be useful in timing later on to know this.

The next aspect the Moon makes is a Square to Mercury in Libra, I feel this is important because I think it may signify a new relationship for you. However, I don't see this relationship going very well. Mercury is in its own Triplicity and Term with no reception with the Moon (you), and you don't have any reception with Mercury either, so while there may be a contact and a prospective romantic interest, I don't see it going very far as you'll eventually split. However, after that I see things getting a lot better as the Moon will then aspect Saturn, lord of the Seventh house of love and partners.
Saturn receives the Moon by dignity and the Moon receives Saturn by triplicity, so there's some very good reception going on here. The Moon and Saturn will meet by a Trine, which indicates an easy introduction and interaction, it doesn't look like there are going to be any mix-ups or differences that can't be resolved here. This looks like it could be your next good relationship, and your next chance at finding what you're looking for.
Unfortunately I can't really give you a time table without knowing when your last relationship ended, because it seems like there's a time system worked into this chart already and knowing when you two split will help me figure that out. :S Complicated, I know.
Take care.